Reviewed by Stephanie Chapman for Readers' Favorite

The Execution, Life and Times of Patrick O’Donnell is historical fiction based on the real-life letters of a condemned man before his death. Gavin O’Donnell’s narrative shares Patrick’s letters to Victor Hugo. Patrick is in Newgate Prison for killing James Carey, and he is determined to share his life story before he goes to the gallows. Patrick begins writing on December 5th, 1883, after he receives his execution date of December 17th, 1883. Despite the newspaper's representation of him as an illiterate Irishman, Patrick describes his father’s efforts to ensure he could read, write, and speak English. He recalls his Uncle Manus’ immigration to America. Shortly after, his father loses the family home. During the Great Famine, Patrick describes his journey to America, where he witnesses his older brother’s death and his time spent in the Grosse Quarantine Islands. He details his relationships, his imprisonment in the military, and how he met Carey.

Gavin O’Donnell includes descriptive commentary in The Execution, Life and Times of Patrick O’Donnell, giving context to the events before each of Patrick’s letters. Newspaper pictures and drawings provide a clear division of each day that passes. Patrick’s first-hand experiences with scandal, murder, and theft are exceptional in their vivid detail. He is adamant and clear about justifying his actions, making it easy to envision each moment. Every letter connected me to his emotions, ranging from optimism to pessimism. Patrick’s life was a struggle, and his definition is: “You don’t choose the cards you are dealt, but you play them the best way you can.” I found his use of the word 'love' confusing. For example, he professes love for Hanora and looks forward to reuniting with her when he dies. However, they never engage in a husband-and-wife relationship. His writing proves that he was fiercely loyal to the people he cared for and that his drive was to protect them.