Author Services
Author Articles

Book Review & Contest Insights from Real Reviews and Submissions
What separates great books from the rest? Below are articles with insights from real reviews and contest submissions—what works, what doesn’t, and how to improve your book. You’ll also find a wide range of articles covering writing, publishing, marketing, and more. Each article has a Comments section so you can read advice from other authors and leave your own.
Why Some Books Win Awards (And Most Don’t) — Insights From Real Contest Submissions
What separates award-winning books from the rest? After evaluating contest submissions across a wide range of genres, certain patterns become clear. Some books consistently rise to the top. Others, even with strong ideas and clear effort behind them, fall short. The difference is rarely dramatic—it...
What We’ve Learned From Reviewing Hundreds of Thousands of Books (And Why Most Don’t Stand Out)
After reviewing and evaluating books across thousands of submissions over the past two decades, certain patterns become impossible to ignore. Some books immediately stand out to reviewers. Others—even well-intentioned ones—fade into the middle or fall short. The difference is rarely luck. It comes down to...
YA and the Girl Who Only Exists to Steal a Boyfriend
Somewhere in a fictional high school cafeteria, a girl with perfect hair has spotted somebody else's boyfriend, which conveniently cancels the rest of her semester. Her designer handbag costs more than most students' cars, yet she has unlimited afternoons available for sabotaging somebody else's relationship. Congratulations, we have met the designated romantic villain of young adult fiction.
You know this girl, regardless of the name the writer gives her. She leans toward him only when his girlfriend approaches, giving everybody in the cafeteria a perfect view. Her interest in him seems practically administrative, like the school assigned her a semester-long project called Make Another Girl Miserable. Seriously, who wakes up excited to do that much unpaid work?
Naturally, she comes from a spectacularly miserable mansion, since enormous kitchens are where parental affection goes to disappear. Her father owns half the town, although her birthday has somehow escaped his calendar. Her mother is permanently away at an expensive retreat with questionable reception. The girl has every material advantage imaginable, yet nobody at home notices whether she comes back for dinner. Her loneliness becomes the story's explanation for why she wants to wreck someone else's happiness.
Here is the part that teenage readers will probably notice instantly. Being ignored at home could influence how somebody approaches affection, particularly when being wanted has become unfamiliar. But deciding that the cure is stealing a specific classmate's boyfriend requires another explanation entirely. There must be something about this particular boy that makes her overlook the obvious misery her pursuit will create. Otherwise, the mansion merely supplies an expensive backdrop for behavior the writer has already decided she must perform.
Even the boyfriend becomes suspiciously passive in these arrangements, receiving flirtation like a phone receiving notifications. He never seems to decide anything until his girlfriend discovers the supposed betrayal. Meanwhile, she is expected to treat the girlfriend's existence as the greatest threat to her happiness. Readers know that attraction rarely obeys such a convenient arrangement. Teenagers make questionable romantic decisions, absolutely, but those decisions still belong to the people making them.
The trope also shrinks this girl's ambitions to one unavailable boy. She could study abroad, yet her grand objective is to persuade another girl's boyfriend to ask her to prom. Imagine her wanting something that survives an entire conversation without mentioning him. Maybe she dreams of having her photography featured in the school newspaper. When he rejects her, she still has a photograph to submit by Friday.
That is why the old boyfriend-stealing villain feels increasingly unbelievable to YA readers. A neglected daughter of wealthy parents could be fascinating when her upbringing has recognizable effects on her decisions. Give her an attraction rooted in something she notices about the boy. Let her mistakenly believe his interest is mutual, then show what that belief costs her friendship with his girlfriend. Most importantly, imagine what she plans to do after the dance. A character with her own life can make a terrible choice that readers understand, even while wishing she would make another one. YA writers, we've caught on to the stereotype, and we're no longer buying the idea that a contemporary girl has absolutely nothing better to do than steal somebody else's boyfriend.
Written by Readers’ Favorite Reviewer Cora May