Author Services

Author Articles

Hundreds of Helpful Articles

Book Review & Contest Insights from Real Reviews and Submissions

What separates great books from the rest? Below are articles with insights from real reviews and contest submissions—what works, what doesn’t, and how to improve your book. You’ll also find a wide range of articles covering writing, publishing, marketing, and more. Each article has a Comments section so you can read advice from other authors and leave your own.

Why Some Books Win Awards (And Most Don’t) — Insights From Real Contest Submissions

What separates award-winning books from the rest? After evaluating contest submissions across a wide range of genres, certain patterns become clear. Some books consistently rise to the top. Others, even with strong ideas and clear effort behind them, fall short. The difference is rarely dramatic—it...

What We’ve Learned From Reviewing Hundreds of Thousands of Books (And Why Most Don’t Stand Out)

After reviewing and evaluating books across thousands of submissions over the past two decades, certain patterns become impossible to ignore. Some books immediately stand out to reviewers. Others—even well-intentioned ones—fade into the middle or fall short. The difference is rarely luck. It comes down to...

You Don't Get a Free Pass with a Scholarship Panic Plot

In certain young adult novels, a scholarship comes with its own emergency alarm. A student misses one assignment, and suddenly the principal is delivering a courtroom speech about expulsion. By lunchtime, she is convinced that tuition funding will disappear before she can turn in another paper. Apparently, the financial aid office runs a reality show elimination round. Financial Aid is not a game of Survivor. I know this because I am up to my eyeballs right now as a student depending on real financial aid, one of which is a partial scholarship.

I understand why writers love this setup, since money can make an ordinary school day feel enormous. A scholarship student may depend on an award to attend a school her family otherwise could never afford. That possibility deserves serious treatment when the next tuition payment looks impossible. The trouble begins when the scholarship becomes a magical punishment device, ready to vanish whenever the plot needs a crisis.

Actual scholarship agreements contain written renewal conditions, which could help fiction writers. An award might require a particular cumulative grade average, while another depends on continued full-time enrollment. Some institutions review eligibility after an academic year, meaning one disastrous Tuesday is hardly the entire calculation. A writer who invents a scholarship can establish its conditions in a sentence, then build suspense around something realistically at risk.

Federal aid at the college level follows a separate rulebook that writers should probably read. Colleges evaluate what they call satisfactory academic progress, including how successfully students complete their coursework. Depending on institutional policy, students may receive a warning period following an unsuccessful evaluation. Students may also appeal when circumstances interfere with academic performance. These procedures vary, which is why a blanket threat of instant expulsion sounds suspicious.

Besides, losing a scholarship follows different rules from expulsion at school. She could remain enrolled while wondering how to afford another semester. Imagine her calculating whether next semester is affordable after discovering that her award requires thirty completed credits this year. That conversation with the scholarship officer could be nerve-racking if withdrawing from a class changes the calculation.


The expectations placed on fictional scholarship students are pretty strange too. Every conversation becomes a test of whether they deserve the opportunity they received. They can barely enjoy a school dance without imagining the principal reviewing their financial aid paperwork. Meanwhile, the wealthy classmates surrounding them seem to have unlimited permission to make mistakes. The result is a strange idea that financial need requires permanent perfection.


For writers, the interesting question is how an actual student lives under the terms of a particular award. She might know her renewal GPA by memory because she checks it after every graded assignment. She might also spend Friday evening at a concert, since scholarship recipients have social lives too. Give her a believable policy to work within, and the anxiety will make sense when something threatens her eligibility.


We've spent enough time refreshing school portals to recognize when a novel invents its own rules. We can recognize a character's financial worries without being told that one late homework submission means instant exile. A scholarship is already important enough to shape someone's choices throughout a school year. Renewal terms? Those are scary. With renewal terms, the story practically writes itself.

Written by Readers’ Favorite Reviewer Cora May