Dear Sam

The Jilted Ex Series (Book 1)

Romance - Comedy
312 Pages
Reviewed on 08/23/2026
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Pikasho Deka for Readers' Favorite

Dear Sam is the first book in The Jilted Ex Series by Beth Carter. Dr. Sam Jennings is a kind-hearted veterinarian who receives the shock of his life when his fiancée, Gabby, unexpectedly leaves him a couple of months before their planned wedding. While his close friends console him as best as they can, Sam develops a crush on his cute new neighbor who has recently moved into town. Faith Donovan is attracted to her new neighbor, Sam, but mistakenly assumes that he has a girlfriend. Meanwhile, she runs into her high school sweetheart, Dallas Adams, at an event where she is catering. Faith also starts writing a relationship advice column for the local newspaper, and one mysterious reader seeks her advice about being relegated to the 'friend zone.' For Faith, it hits very close to home.

Full of drama and humor, Dear Sam is perfect for rom-com lovers. It was such an easy, entertaining read for me. Beth Carter tells a charming love story featuring "jilted exes" who do their best to stop the protagonists from ending up together. Carter's pacing is brilliant, crafting an absorbing narrative that is a breeze to read. I found the characters very funny and likable, and I'm not even talking about the two main protagonists. Even the secondary characters are fun to read about. Sam and Faith's interactions will have you rooting for the two of them. But I also enjoyed the scenes involving Sam's friends, as well as Faith's catering adventures. Overall, this is an absolute treat for contemporary romance readers. I had a blast with this novel, and you should too.

Asher Syed

Dear Sam by Beth Carter follows veterinarian Sam Jennings in the town of Tranquil, where his fiancée, Gabby, leaves weeks before their wedding after accusing him of putting his veterinary practice first. As Sam tries to rebuild his life, new neighbor Faith Donovan starts Cookie Queen, a baking business, and accepts a job writing an anonymous advice column for The Tranquil Press under the name Evie. Their growing friendship becomes complicated when Dallas Adams, Faith’s former boyfriend, returns to town and opens a rival veterinary clinic across from Sam’s. Sam begins reading Evie’s column for guidance as he faces changes in his business and growing feelings for Faith, unaware that the woman offering him advice is living next door and keeping her connection to the column secret.

Beth Carter’s Dear Sam is a delightful small-town romantic comedy that is pure fun to follow. Chemistry is present in small moments, which comes through during a backyard dinner when Faith shivers after their fingers touch over a wineglass. The spark suits this romance perfectly, since Carter keeps Sam’s life as a veterinarian present as Faith arrives with a life of her own. The author has a gift for creating visual moments. At the Holmes farm, Sam crosses toward a faded red barn where straw covers the floor as Carol watches through a window during a difficult calf delivery. Glamour Pets has a memorable look, with a flowing waterfall beside a fireplace shifting from blue to green. Readers seeking affectionate small-town love stories should put Dear Sam on their reading list.

Anne-Marie Reynolds

Dear Sam by Beth Carter follows Dr. Sam Jennings, a small‑town veterinarian whose life is upended when his fiancée disappears two months before their wedding, leaving behind only a brief note and an empty house. As he buries himself in caring for his animal patients and tries to ignore the growing threat of a flashy new rival clinic across the street, his new neighbor Faith Donovan quietly builds her Cookie Queen business and anonymously pens a local advice column. When Sam begins writing in to the column for guidance and unknowingly shares his heart with Faith’s alter ego, their paths start to cross in ways neither expects, leading to a gentle, slow‑burn journey of second chances, small‑town support, and a romance that grows out of everyday moments rather than grand gestures.

Dear Sam by Beth Carter is a warm and steady romance that leans into the familiar rhythms of small‑town life. It’s a character‑driven story that gives readers time to settle in and get to know Sam and Faith through their routines, worries, and small personal triumphs. Sam’s determination to move forward feels genuine, and Faith’s creativity and resilience add a homely, comforting tone to the book. The dual viewpoints make it easy to follow both Sam and Faith, and you get to know them at a steady pace that suits the story. The small‑town setting adds a familiar backdrop, with neighbors and friends who each bring their own presence to the pages. This steady, character‑focused romance builds gradually, with enough warmth and everyday detail to keep you turning the pages. The characters feel real, each with their own strengths and flaws, and the story keeps its attention on their personal journeys. A lovely read for anyone who enjoys slow‑build relationships and small‑town stories with a gentle, uplifting tone.

K T Bowes

In Dear Sam by Beth Carter, Sam Jennings—Tranquil’s favorite veterinarian—is devastated when his fiancée leaves him two months before their expensive wedding. He’s left floundering and confused by her cryptic note claiming he loved his animals more than he loved her. Just as he channels all his passion into his vet practice, a shiny new rival opens across the street and starts luring Sam’s customers away. Facing emotional and financial ruin, the heartbroken vet has nowhere left to turn. Faith Donovan is new to Tranquil, moving in next door to Sam and launching her baking business. They seem destined for the friend zone despite their obvious mutual attraction. But when Faith becomes the advice columnist for the local newspaper, she writes under a pen name, and Sam has no idea he’s pouring out his troubles to the girl next door.

Dear Sam is a clever friends-to-lovers romance with a charming girl-next-door arc. The dual narration offers insight into both characters’ struggles. I loved Sam’s portrayal as a genuinely nice guy without the usual ego issues found in macho romances. It made him feel more realistic and easier to sympathize with as both his love life and his business hit major roadblocks. Faith is independent and gutsy, and Beth Carter makes her relatable. I appreciated how the author crafted Faith as self-sufficient and capable, not in desperate need of a man to fulfill her goals. This is a clean, wholesome, happily ever after romance with all the ingredients for a perfect summer read. Beth Carter’s cozy descriptions of the little town of Tranquil give it an old-world charm and innocence that made me want to live there.

Divine Zape

Beth Carter’s Dear Sam opens with a small-town veterinarian, Sam, discovering that his fiancée, Gabby, has walked out on him just when they are preparing for their wedding. He tries to understand why, makes excuses, and hopes she will eventually come back. But reality slowly sinks in: she has ghosted him; she has gone. So, he turns his focus on his work, tending to the animals that are more loyal than humans. Meanwhile, Faith moves in next door and starts a cookie business, eventually becoming “Evie,” the town’s new anonymous advice columnist. Things get worse for Sam when a new vet named Dallas arrives and steals Sam’s clients. He happens to be Faith’s ex and is a flashy person. Faith helps Sam fight back. Along the way, Sam writes to "Evie" for love advice, unaware he is writing to Faith, and what follows are revelations and a twist that no one will see coming.

Beth Carter’s book had more than I'd hoped for. In addition to the complex characters, it has heart, humor, and a twisty plot. Sam is kind and most often appears to be absolutely clueless. The banter with his loyal staff and three goofy friends augments the humor and injects life into the story. Dear Sam cleverly captures small-town drama while delivering a captivating tale about second chances. The author plants questions in your mind regarding why Gabby left, making you want to know if she will come back, then brings in Faith and increases the tension. Faith’s secret identity is a device that keeps the suspense growing until everything finally blows up. The steady pacing makes it more like a slice-of-life story, with baking scenes and pet emergencies filling the gaps. It is a delightful read from start to finish.