The Gingerbread That Stayed


Children - General
48 Pages
Reviewed on 11/20/2026
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Inga Buccella for Readers' Favorite

The Gingerbread That Stayed by Allison and Scott Fennema is a meaningful holiday story. The story unfolds as a mother takes out her special blue mixing bowl to prepare the annual gingerbread cookies with her family. The children, their mom, and their dad enjoy putting their own special touches on their gingerbread cookies. Knowing that the cookies will soon be eaten, the mother pulls a tin from a kitchen shelf. Inside is a gingerbread man. She explains how choosing just one cookie to keep in the tin will keep their baking tradition alive. Over the subsequent Christmas seasons, the children grow up and move out of the house to start their own families. Eventually, they will share their mother’s baking tradition. As Decembers pass, they, too, teach their children to collect memories in the shape of gingerbread men. This children’s story would make a great gift for any child. With the cookie recipe in the back of the book, readers may be inspired to start their own baking traditions.

Poetic and poignant, The Gingerbread That Stayed is destined to become a classic story. Allison and Scott Fennema have created a memorable tale sure to delight readers of any age. What I found most engaging is the deep meaning that goes beyond baking gingerbread cookies. In addition, colorful, realistic, but whimsical illustrations fly off the pages. Most of all, I was amazed by the creative storytelling. The story is both unique and touching. Although baking may be the conductor of the mystical energy that flows through this story, I feel the real power comes from the family’s shared tradition, which seems to stop time, if only for a moment. Cookies are consumable. However, warm, delicious family memories aren’t made for only one season, or even one generation. Instead, they may live on. Fortunately, every holiday season offers a new chance to make more.

Emily-Jane Hills Orford

Magic lives in the wonderful, spicy smell of freshly made gingerbread cookies. And there’s also magic in the spicy smell of gingerbread cookies made years ago and kept in a special place, like stored memories. In Allison Fennema and Scott Fennema’s The Gingerbread That Stayed, a family comes together every year for that special tradition of making gingerbread cookies. There’s a special bowl and a special routine, beginning with Mom calling out to everyone with a single word, “Time,” and Dad humming his special tune. The children are full of anticipation and excitement, and there’s laughter floating through the kitchen along with the flour and spices. The cookies aren’t just cookies; they’re more than just a shape that sparkles with decorations carefully adorned. The cookies are, as Mom aptly announces, “It’s tradition.”

Allison Fennema and Scott Fennema’s picture book, The Gingerbread That Stayed, is a sweet and endearing story about traditions and the importance of family togetherness time. The plot follows the family tradition of making gingerbread cookies at the beginning of the Christmas season and the ritual that continues even as the children grow up and have families of their own. The story is more than just a gingerbread-making ritual; it’s about the memories that grow each year as one cookie is placed in a special tin, saved to recall the wonders and magic of Christmases past and present. The language is simple, making it easy for young readers to follow along and improve their reading skills. The illustrations are bright, bold, and colorful – truly magical in their presentation. I loved this story, and I know you will, too.

S. Mathur

The Gingerbread That Stayed by Allison Fennema and Scott Fennema is a story about family traditions passed down over the years. Every year in December, when there’s snow on the ground, Mom pulls a large blue mixing bowl from the top shelf. This is officially the start of the holiday season, and it’s time to start baking. Everyone helps to mix the dough, cut the shapes, and decorate the warm, fragrant cookies. Then they choose one cookie each and crunch on them happily. Except one year, the middle child doesn’t eat her gingerbread person, but leaves it on the windowsill. That’s when she discovers a family tradition - every year, Mom saves a gingerbread cookie in a tin box. So that’s where her gingerbread person goes. This continues every year, even when the kids are grown and have their own children.

The simple magic and fun of doing things together as a family make The Gingerbread That Stayed a very appealing book. Allison Fennema and Scott Fennema bring winter enchantment to life with gentle words that match the richly detailed, dreamlike pictures. Readers of all ages will relate to the simple things remembered from childhood. I especially liked the part where the narrator realizes that saving one gingerbread each year is a way of saving memories. And, of course, everyone will love the easy-to-follow family recipe for gingerbread at the back of the book, so that you can make your own traditions and memories. This book would be a great Christmas gift for families to read together.

Jennifer Senick

Have you ever kept something because it reminded you of a special time? In The Gingerbread That Stayed by Allison Fennema, a cookie becomes more than just a treat. The story begins when Mom takes out a big blue bowl from the cupboard. Everyone knows what that means! There's plenty to do before the gingerbread cookies are ready to eat. And each person gets involved. Once the dough is prepared, the children choose which cookie cutter they’d like to use. The shapes include gingerbread people, stars, trees, and even a reindeer. Dad hums Christmas songs, although he doesn't always get the tune right! Of course, someone has to sneak a sprinkle, too. After the cookies come out of the oven and have time to cool, they get busy with the decorations. They use icing and all kinds of candy. They all start enjoying their treats, except for one of the kids. The child is not ready to eat a gingerbread person with two red buttons and a crooked smile. So, they decide to save it. When Mom finds it, she has something rather interesting to share about when she grew up.

The Gingerbread That Stayed by Allison Fennema is a lovely Christmas story. I really liked the message about how important traditions can be, especially when they're passed down from one generation to another. The idea of keeping a gingerbread cookie might seem a little strange at first, but I thought it was very sweet. There was also a magical quality to the story, which I loved. The descriptions of the kitchen and all the baking made it easy to picture what was happening. This would be a great read to share with my kindergarten class around the holidays. We could decorate cookies and make a chart showing how many students like them and how many don't. I'd also ask the kids to tell us about some of the things their families do each year. I'm sure we'd hear quite a few interesting customs! Scott Fennema's illustrations are gorgeous. I enjoyed the Christmas lights, snow-covered trees, and all the little details on the tasty treats. There's even a recipe at the end, which was a nice surprise. I'd recommend this book for homes, classrooms, and libraries. Besides being a cute holiday story, it might encourage children to ask their parents about the traditions they enjoyed growing up.

Olga Markova

The Gingerbread That Stayed is a fabulous children’s Christmas story by Allison Fennema and Scott Fennema. Dedicated to their family, the story is about the tradition of starting the Christmas season by baking gingerbread cookies on the first cold night of December. The story also shares the important rule to keep one gingerbread cookie as a memento. The family’s middle daughter tells this story, tracing the tradition from her childhood. She remembers her mother’s special blue bowl used for the family’s baking event, the old keepsake tin, and how her parents and siblings decorated and enjoyed the gingerbread cookies. Then she becomes a mother and passes the gingerbread baking and keepsake rule to her own child. But what makes this gingerbread bake-and-keepsake tradition so special?

What a fantastic, magical, and heartwarming story! Allison and Scott Fennema’s The Gingerbread That Stayed gave me so many delightful moments. Superbly crafted, artsy illustrations stole my breath away, enhancing the story with truly Christmassy, atmospheric visuals of the snowy scenery and loving family enjoying their tradition. I absolutely loved how inspiring the gingerbread baking scenes looked. And I felt the Christmas spirit in every scene, as the family came together to bake and decorate gingerbread cookies on a cold December night. The story’s message of passing traditions down through generations was beyond praiseworthy. Last but not least, the family’s gingerbread cookie recipe was the gem that made this book truly special. As I set off to try this recipe, I highly recommend this wonderful book to all families who want to make Christmas memorable and special.