The Pit


Fiction - Drama
263 Pages
Reviewed on 11/21/2026
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Rabia Tanveer for Readers' Favorite

The Pit by Andrew Kellan is a psychological suspense novel. Andrew once gave a girl named Carolina a safe place to stay for one night and then watched her go back to a strict, controlling religious home. Years later, Carolina is a mother, and her young daughter, Emma, begins spending more and more time with him. To Emma, he becomes “Papi” and “Grandulón,” the big friend who takes her to the park, buys her little dresses, and sings her favorite songs with her. But the more he sees of Emma’s life, the more he worries about what's happening at home. Every time he thinks about stepping in, he has to ask whether he’s helping or making things worse. The story follows him from Carolina’s childhood through the years he spends with Emma and the guilt he carries afterward. Can he really save Emma? Or does he need saving too?

Author Andrew Kellan created a heartfelt, thought-provoking story without making it dramatic. The narrative style is exceptional, and I liked how honest Andrew, the protagonist, was. I loved how he shared his doubts, fears, and mistakes. He doesn’t try to be a hero. The small moments with Emma were my favorite, like her twirling in her dress and asking Alexa to play “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” again and again. Somehow, those moments brought tears to my eyes. The short chapters and the pit story at the start made the book easy to follow, and the ending left me thinking for a long time. The Pit is perfect for readers who like emotional, character-driven stories and moral questions with no easy answers.

Grant Leishman

The Pit by Andrew Kellan is an unusual drama that strikes at the very core of our beliefs about love and helping our neighbors. Carolina is the daughter of family friends. One night, when Carolina was just a child, Andrew gave shelter to the young girl, who was clearly troubled. Years later, Carolina, now a mother, is struggling to cope with motherhood and her troubled relationship. Turning to Andrew, she seeks help in raising her daughter Emma and asks Andrew if he can help by looking after Emma when she is away at work. Keen to help Carolina and wanting the best for Emma, Andrew agrees. As time passes, Andrew’s love for Emma becomes deeper and more intense. He is concerned about the young girl’s future, but what can he do? He is not her father, and he has no legal rights regarding Emma’s future. When Carolina and Emma suddenly disappear from Andrew’s life, he is distraught and bereft. Determined to find out where the pair have gone, he searches for them but with little success. Without warning, Andrew finds himself in the middle of an investigation that could threaten his own freedom and safety.

The Pit is a fascinating look at the limits of friendship and love that must be placed upon those who have no direct familial relationship with the children they care for. Author Andrew Kellan has used the analogy of falling into a pit to describe the dangers of becoming overly invested in someone else’s children. I appreciated the mental arguments Andrew had with himself as he explored the avenues for helping Emma despite the parents' and grandparents' suspicions and doubts about his motives. The codependency that developed between Andrew and Emma was perhaps the highlight of the narrative. Although Emma, as a very young child, totally relied on Andrew to fulfill her daily needs, equally Andrew relied heavily on Emma to fulfill his need to be wanted, needed, and useful with his own children already grown up. His perception of his role as Emma’s caregiver clashed heavily with others' perception of the actions of an elderly man being alone with and looking after a vulnerable young girl. The presumption of an ulterior motive on Andrew’s part says much about our society’s conditioning as to the generalized impulses and actions of all men rather than just a tiny minority. What comes through loud and clear from this work is that perception is often more powerful than truth and reality when people judge a set of circumstances. This is a thought-provoking work and one that will have readers pondering long after they have read the final chapter. It is a moving tale of misperception that I thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend.

Ruffina Oserio

By the time you finish reading Andrew Kellan’s The Pit, you are left with an important question: “What do we do after we have seen what we have seen?” That question accompanies Andrew from the moment he first meets the pastor’s daughter on a beach. She has a brief moment of freedom at the beach and runs like someone who has just found an open door after being shut in for far too long. When Carolina is cast out, he decides to protect her, but he arrives too late to stop the adoption of her first daughter. After several years, Carolina returns with Emma, a toddler whose silence and expressions suggest deep-seated fear. Andrew becomes her refuge, paying for preschool, taking her to Disneyland, and becoming “Grandulón” and “Papi” to her. Yet, Emma always has to return to the unstable home. What happens when Carolina moves north, and a man’s devotion is mistaken for suspicion?

Andrew Kellan inspires admiration as a character, yet something about him feels deeply sad and lonely. The pathos grows through his desperate desire to protect Emma, and the reader keeps asking why as they follow the story. But his struggles in the later part of the story open a new door into his psyche, revealing a man whose brokenness forces him to help others. His connection with little Emma becomes a path to touching his old wounds. In The Pit, the author uses compelling metaphors to evoke the idea of being thrown into a pit: religious certainty, displacement, selective blindness, legal helplessness, and guilt. The idea of being trapped pervades the plot. The first-person narrative voice is compelling, and the narrator repeats phrases in a way that draws readers back to specific scenes and prompts them to rethink specific emotions and situations. This novel is profoundly gripping and bittersweet, with characters that are hard to forget.

Jamie Michele

Andrew Kellan’s The Pit follows Andrew, a father in Argentina whose young son befriends Anastacio, the youngest child of a local pastor. Through the boys, he gets to know Anastacio’s older sister Carolina, whose father governs the household through an uncompromising interpretation of Scripture. During a day at the beach, Carolina asks to live with Andrew’s family, leaving him worried about what awaits her at home. Their lives continue to intersect over the years, until Carolina returns with her daughter Emma, whose withdrawn manner troubles him. Hoping to offer the little girl some security, Andrew opens his home to her, and she begins calling him Papi. As their affection grows, he finds himself facing difficult decisions about his responsibility to a child whose parents retain the right to decide how she is raised.

Andrew Kellan’s The Pit is fantastic literary fiction, and Emma is someone we genuinely want to root for. The author fleshes her out as a spirited little girl whose delight in new experiences becomes infectious, such as when she dances at Luna Tucumana and requests another song. Andrew is a wonderfully sympathetic narrator, and his devotion to Emma shows in the quiet ways he tries to protect her happiness. He lengthens the Sunday drive home while Emma sleeps, and it is beautiful and heartbreaking, under the circumstances. Where the author truly shines is in bringing everyday settings to life, from the bouncing rubber mats of a trampoline hall to a restaurant filled with singing strangers celebrating Emma’s eighth birthday. Well written and absorbing, readers who enjoy literary fiction about family bonds will adore this.

Miche Arendse

In The Pit by Andrew Kellan, the story follows a narrator whose life becomes deeply intertwined with a young woman named Carolina and, eventually, her daughter, Emma. It all begins when he meets Carolina as a young girl and realizes that she is growing up in a controlling household dominated by her religious father. When she eventually finds herself without a home, he tries to offer her support, but repeatedly struggles with how far he should go to help her. Years later, Carolina becomes a mother to Sofía, but financial difficulties and family circumstances result in her daughter being adopted by another family. The narrator is deeply affected by this loss and gradually develops a close bond with Carolina. When she eventually returns with another daughter, Emma, he becomes increasingly involved in the little girl's life, offering her a safe place where she can experience the happiness and security of childhood. However, as Emma grows older, concerns about her circumstances and Carolina's decisions become increasingly difficult to ignore. When Carolina eventually leaves with Emma, the narrator is left struggling with uncertainty, guilt, and the painful question of whether he did enough to protect someone who depended on him.

I found The Pit by Andrew Kellan to be a deeply emotional and thought-provoking read. What stood out to me most was how the author explores the complicated nature of helping someone, particularly when good intentions are not always enough to change their circumstances. I liked how the relationship between the narrator and Emma develops through ordinary, everyday moments, making their eventual separation all the more heartbreaking. The writing is reflective and sometimes philosophical, with the recurring metaphor of the pit giving the story an added layer of meaning. It also makes you question the difference between being concerned about someone and actually taking responsibility for doing something to help them. Although the narrative can be quite introspective, I thought its emotional depth and difficult questions made it worthwhile. This book will particularly appeal to readers who enjoy character-driven stories that explore family relationships, abandonment, guilt, compassion, and the lasting consequences of the choices we make.