The Harlot of St. Cecelia's


Fiction - Mystery - Historical
310 Pages
Reviewed on 09/03/2026
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Olga Markova for Readers' Favorite

The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s is a fabulous, cozy murder mystery that opens the Inspector Garrett Mysteries series by talented author Darcy Graves. The story transports us to London, 1923. The assistant head librarian at St. Cecelia’s Library in Dayneton discovers the body of a young French actress, Isabelle Jalbert, in the library’s Athenaeum. It looks like Isabelle was strangled. Examining the crime scene, the police find two people who had been locked in the book vault. One is Isabelle’s estranged husband and the library’s patron, Simon Cross. Another is an assistant librarian, Eden Brior. The police suspect Simon, who had a row with Isabelle in the library before she died. Eden and Simon’s sister, Meg, join forces to clear Simon’s name. But will they find out who strangled Isabelle Jalbert?

What an amazingly delightful story! Reading The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s, I lost myself in interwar England. I appreciated how Darcy Graves transposed her interest in history into this fantastic novel, and I savored her writing style and scenic descriptions of the period’s way of life. Witty, tasteful humor permeated every scene, and one of my favorites was “the woman must have simply abounded in husbands.” The intrigue was superb, and I thoroughly enjoyed investigating the mystery. All in all, it was a perfect, riveting read on all counts, and I can’t wait to read the upcoming sequel, The Treasure of Mayfair. I highly recommend this remarkable, beyond-praise novel to cozy murder mystery fans. The discussion questions at the book’s end make it a perfect choice for book clubs.

Anne-Marie Reynolds

The Harlot of St. Cecelia's by Darcy Graves opens with Eden Brior wanting nothing more than a quiet day at St. Cecelia's Library, but that plan falls apart the moment Simon Cross talks his way into borrowing a book he shouldn't have. That night, the two of them get accidentally locked in the library's book vault together. By morning, Eden emerges to find the police there and the body of Simon's estranged wife, a glamorous French actress, lying over a chair in the library nave. Detective Inspector William Garrett is convinced Simon is his man and tells Eden firmly to leave the investigating to him, but Eden isn't so sure the case is as simple as it looks. Eden teams up with Simon's fierce sister Meg to dig into a web of secrets that stretches from the London stage to the drawing rooms of Jazz Age society, where everyone seems to be hiding something and the truth is far more dangerous than anyone expects.

The Harlot of St. Cecelia's by Darcy Graves is a mystery that feels of its time, and I loved how grounded it is in the aftermath of the war. The main characters really grow over the course of the story, starting out guarded and unsure of themselves and gradually becoming more open and confident as the investigation forces them to face things they'd rather have avoided. The pacing takes its time at first, letting you mull over the fog and the tension of a place where everyone has manners but not everyone has scruples, before pulling everything tightly together in the final chapters. Every character feels like they're hiding something. The author does a great job of making several of them plausible suspects, so the reveal actually lands as a surprise rather than something you saw coming from page one. It's atmospheric, well researched, and quietly devastating in places. Anyone who loves Golden Age detective fiction, or just a smart mystery with real emotional stakes, will want to read this book.

Lucinda E Clarke

The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s by Darcy Graves is a murder mystery set in England between the two World Wars. Eden works in a library, a rather large one, attached to a university. On this particular night, she and a young man named Simon are locked in a storeroom. Upstairs, a murder is committed; Isabelle, an actress with a dubious reputation, Simon's estranged wife, is found strangled. The lead policeman on the case, Detective Inspector William Garrett, is pressured by his boss to charge Simon with the crime. However, he has his doubts, even as the evidence piles up. Simon’s sister Meg teams up with Eden to clear Simon’s name. There are many other suspects, a whole cast of actors with conflicting alibis, some true and some false. As more information comes to light, the plot becomes even more tangled.

Author Darcy Graves introduces us to several delightful characters in The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s: Eden, worried she is under suspicion for murder; Simon, who is reluctant to cooperate; and a hard-working detective with a daft constable who has no idea what to say and is more of a liability than an asset. The reader is kept guessing up to the last chapter in this easy read that is both fun and a little intriguing. The descriptions take you back a hundred years with great attention to detail of London in that period. I particularly liked the detective’s search for new lodgings and his meeting with prospective landladies. I liked the cover, which shows the atmosphere of the story, and the chapter heading quotes are interesting and varied. If you like both period drama and a good detective tale, then this is a book you will enjoy.

Grant Leishman

The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s by Darcy Graves is a classic, well-constructed “whodunit” set in 1920s London. Eden Brior is an American expat working at the St. Cecelia’s Library. One night she is accidentally locked in the library vault with Simon Cross, a charming but roguish Englishman. Upon their release the next morning, they discover the body of Simon’s wife, Isabelle, a French actress of some renown, draped over a chair. As Detective Inspector William Garrett begins his investigation of Isabelle’s murder, he begins to uncover a web of connections that point directly at Simon Cross as being the miscreant. But Eden Brior is convinced that Simon is innocent and sets out to do her own investigation and prove his innocence. As the investigation continues, the mystery deepens, and more and more potential suspects come to light. What Eden ultimately discovers is a darkness that underlies the surface of glitz and glamor that the Jazz Age of 1920s London projected.

The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s is a gentle, cozy journey into the frivolous age of the 1920s. Author Darcy Graves has created a murder mystery and a heroine redolent of Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple. Eden Brior is perhaps the opposite of Miss Marple in many ways, as a young American, but her intuition and perception of the facts surrounding the case are where the corollary lies. Despite her rather shy and retiring nature, Eden was prepared to follow her “gut feeling” on Simon’s innocence and to put herself in dangerous circumstances to prove it. I appreciated the calm and methodical nature of Detective Inspector William Garrett, who was determined to let the evidence speak for itself and not jump to conclusions based on emotion. I loved the counterpoint between him and his superior, whose sole concern was to arrest and convict, especially as the evidence pointed so heavily at Simon Cross. Garrett’s disdain for his young assistant also led to some humorous interactions as he desperately tried to keep Sergeant Bradey away from the investigation and stop him from making comments that could be detrimental to the investigation during questioning witnesses and suspects. This book is a gentle, pleasant read that murder mystery lovers will enjoy, without any true violence or gore. I thoroughly enjoyed and highly recommend it.

Alma Boucher

In The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s by Darcy Graves, Eden Brior, a librarian at St. Cecelia’s Library, is forced to stay after work to close the library. Before closing, Eden witnesses Simon Cross and his estranged wife Isabelle engaged in a heated argument. While returning books to the rare books vault, Eden and Simon are locked inside the vault. Their overnight in the vault takes a shocking turn when they are rescued the following morning by police responding to a murder nearby. Isabelle has been found strangled and deliberately posed on a chair. Detective Inspector William Garrett is instructed to close the case quickly and is convinced he has the killer. Eden cannot accept that Simon is guilty. Refusing to stand by while an innocent man faces being charged, she begins asking questions of her own. As Eden digs deeper, she knows that Detective Inspector Garrett has the wrong suspect.

The Harlot of St. Cecelia’s by Darcy Graves is filled with mystery from the beginning. The engaging writing brings the surroundings to life. Eden went all out to prove that Simon was innocent, while Detective Inspector Garrett was convinced the case was closed. Several plots were woven throughout the story without detracting from each other. With all the twists and unanswered questions, I just kept turning the pages. The book was brilliantly written and well researched. I enjoyed the mysteries, history, and investigations in the plot. The book was much more than I expected, and I could not put it down. I find myself, from time to time, still pondering over the book.