The Rocking Horse Agreement


Fiction - Fantasy - Epic
Kindle Edition
Reviewed on 11/10/2026
Buy on Amazon

    Book Review

Reviewed by Jamie Michele for Readers' Favorite

Scott Everett’s The Rocking Horse Agreement follows Emmy Pen, a kindergarten teacher whose life changes when a British solicitor identifies her as the heir to a historic American estate. Alongside the inheritance comes an unusual obligation requiring Emmy to search for a missing trunk tied to the legendary Pendragon bloodline and a secret wartime pact between President Franklin Roosevelt and King George VI. Accompanied by Myrla, her closest friend since childhood, Emmy enters a guarded castle whose employees have maintained the property for generations. Its library has already attracted seventeen-year-old Aliki McCord, who studies old navigation records to investigate her parents’ mysterious disappearance at sea. As scientists begin reporting falling ocean levels, American officials revisit the wartime agreement, placing Emmy’s unexpected royal connection within a mystery reaching far beyond her inheritance.

Scott Everett’s The Rocking Horse Agreement is an incredible contemporary fantasy, and its Arthurian world is as inventive as it is expansive. Emmy is remarkably compassionate, commissioning a play area for employees’ children and taking Aliki hang gliding for summer fun. I love Myrla, Emmy’s mischievous friend, who flirts shamelessly with Secret Service trainee Skoldolfr by calling him Jack. Everett’s world-building is massive, particularly where ancient customs meet modern security. For example, a stone dragon clutches a globe above the library doorway as Secret Service agents guard the entrance. Still, it’s Everett’s near-cinematic descriptions of landscapes that steal the scenes, from the sun-bleached boardwalk beside Aliki’s beach house to sunrise over the boats moored at Watch Hill Harbor. Beautifully written and bold, readers who enjoy political intrigue with an Arthurian twist will adore this.

Joshua Olokodana

When Emmy and Myrla sent their DNA samples to a gene-testing service, they did not expect to find a solicitor and an ambassador, accompanied by the United States Secret Service, at their doorstep. Emmy is further surprised when they reveal that she is the sole heir to a two-thousand-acre estate as long as she commits to finding a missing trunk and disavows her claim to the English throne. It turns out that seawater is escaping through a rift beneath the ocean, building up to an earth-wide volcanic apocalypse, and only the chosen owner of the items in the trunk can stop it. As they set out to find it, they meet Aliki, the butler's teenage daughter, in the estate's library and allow her to tag along, but when the item in the trunk does not respond to Emmy and Myrla, Aliki is forced to try. Surely, the weight of the world cannot be placed on the shoulders of a seventeen-year-old, can it? Read The Rocking Horse Agreement by Scott Everett to find out.

The Rocking Horse Agreement is an urban fantasy that features a unique combination of modern settings and medieval mystical elements. It stimulates the reader's imagination with spectacular imagery and a bold premise. The plot progresses from a hair-raising prologue to a fairy-tale beginning and concludes in a high-stakes affair. Despite being a plot-driven story, the characters show personality as they evolve throughout their character arcs, while the obstacles they face give the story a sense of adventure. Scott Everett's incorporation of humor, plot twists, and mythology also makes the narrative engaging. However, the preface is my favorite part; it makes a promise that the rest of the book fulfills. The Rocking Horse Agreement explores apocalyptic and orphanhood themes and maintains a broad appeal to a general fantasy fiction audience.