Reviewed by K.C. Finn for Readers' Favorite
Conspiracy by Means of Natural Selection by Sherman P. Bastarache is a non-fiction exploration of how conspiracy theories might have developed through natural selection. Bastarache argues that the human mind, shaped by evolutionary processes, has an inherent tendency to create and believe in conspiracy theories. He examines the role of social and ancient cultures in shaping belief systems and our desire for control over the world. The book challenges readers from all backgrounds, urging a search for truth over acceptance of falsehoods. Bastarache’s bold approach to addressing a universal yet controversial subject shows a fearless commitment to intellectual honesty and I was absolutely fascinated by this exploration of why we want to believe in proposed ‘truths’ from cover to cover. His integration of evolutionary theory with philosophical inquiries is uniquely placed to show us exactly why we’re so prone to conspiracy beliefs and how the human mind has shifted in this direction generation after generation.
The writing style is deeply immersive, almost novel-like in the enthusiasm and persuasiveness that leaps off the pages, and this in itself leans into the whole excitement and appeal of the conspiracy itself. The book also challenges a wide audience including religious and scientific communities to demonstrate how truly universal the human mind and its capacity for belief is. However, it’s also very respectful of diverse communities and doesn’t seek to devalue the beliefs we choose to hold close to our hearts, just to explain them. Instead, Sherman P. Bastarache’s refreshing call for truth-seeking crosses these many societal divisions, inspiring more critical and accepting thinking in a polarized world. Overall, Conspiracy by Means of Natural Selection is a highly engrossing read for anyone interested in psychology, biology, and society, and I highly recommend it.