Conniption Creek


Fiction - Literary
Kindle Edition
Reviewed on 03/16/2026
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Manik Chaturmutha for Readers' Favorite

Conniption Creek by Earl L Carlson tells the story of the unfortunate residents of Conniption City, a town built in a valley that functions like a "topographical Venus flytrap." The village was founded by swindlers who lured prospectors with fake gold, leaving only the feckless and bewildered to populate it. As a record-breaking spring thaw causes the local creek to swell into a raging torrent, the townspeople, including the delusional, military-obsessed Mayor Mitby Sather, the hypocritical Saint Birdie Twine, and the frustrated teacher Leola B. Grundy, ignore the impending doom in favor of petty squabbles and misplaced faith. At the same time, Kayayah, leader of the Spirit Lake Nimi'ipuu, observes from the mountains as the spirits of his ancestors gear up to reclaim their land.

Conniption Creek by Earl L Carlson is a biting, darkly hilarious satire that reads like a cross between Mark Twain’s wit and a fever dream. The title is incredibly apt; it refers not just to the literal body of water, but also to the "conniptions" or fits of irrational behavior that define the town's ridiculous culture. The book is remarkable for depicting a natural disaster with the same nonchalant absurdity as a bar-room brawl, using the flood as an expansive metaphor for human arrogance and deliberate ignorance. The world-building is incredibly vivid, with the valley becoming a character in its own right. The chapter titles, such as "Faith Is the Most Foolish of All the Virtues" and "The Cecil Grundy School of Economics," are extremely clever, establishing a lighthearted and satirical tone. The prose is engaging, and the "Comedy of the Darkly Absurd" subtitle is delivered in spades. I recommend this book for its incisive social commentary and distinctively cynical charm.

Carol Thompson

Conniption Creek by Earl L Carlson is set in the quirky village of Conniption City, where an impending flood seems to be the community’s main concern. The residents trust Saint Birdie Twine, a local holy woman who quietly reassures them that the waters are receding, even as the river continues to rise and sweep people away. While danger looms at their doorstep, the townspeople remain focused on their own ambitions, rivalries, and personal issues. Mayor Mitby Sather, a former army mess sergeant, envisions a political future beyond his small office. Bishop Obediah Twine aims for the papacy, despite not being part of the Catholic Church. Miss Sympathy Jo Jacobson faces her fortieth birthday and anxiously searches for companionship, while others deal with their own strange priorities. All around them, the waters keep rising, and the townspeople act as if daily grievances matter more than the approaching danger.

Earl L Carlson maintains a lively, playful tone that complements the book’s dark humor. He depicts the town’s characters through quick, vivid sketches that reveal their ambitions and contradictions with carefully chosen details. The pacing is steady as the author shifts focus from one resident to another. The humor emerges from the contrast between the approaching flood and the characters’ stubborn focus on their own concerns. Readers who enjoy satire will appreciate how Conniption Creek highlights the quirks of political ambition, religious authority, and small-town life. The story builds humor through repetition and escalating absurdity as the villagers maintain their routines while the water rises. Fans of Kurt Vonnegut-style literary satire will find much to enjoy in the playful narrative and sharp insights throughout Conniption Creek. Baby Boomers and Gen X readers may find a touch of nostalgia here, remembering when mothers warned they were about to have a “conniption fit.”

Robert A. Groves

Conniption Creek by Earl L. Carlson is a dark satirical comedy about communal delusion in an isolated frontier town. The story follows a cast of vividly developed characters that collide with natural, cultural, and spiritual forces. While there is no single protagonist, Mayor Mitby Sather anchors the ensemble. He is a rigid military man turned small-town mayor. As a town crisis unfolds, he brings his military habits to bear on civic responsibilities, making him both absurd and dangerous. Each of the townspeople has their own personal motives that conflict with the mayor’s mission to save Conniption City. In contrast, Kayayah, leader of the Spirit Lake Band of Nimi’ipuu, exemplifies restraint and patience in the face of challenges. The tension between what Sather and Kayayah individually represent is where Conniption Creek does much of its strongest work.

When I had finished reading Earl L. Carlson’s Conniption Creek, I was both impressed and unsettled. I was most impressed by his ability to sustain a savage humor throughout while also creating a sense of moral seriousness. As the town's governance began to break down during the crisis, I found characters like Leola B. Grundy more believable than fictional. Although the storylines about civic order and education were humorous, they also created a feeling of discomfort. By the end, the use of a crisis developed beyond a plot theme and became a reckoning. Carlson has crafted a clever, complex, and entertaining story that will appeal to a wide adult audience. I enjoyed the book and highly recommend it to others.

Grant Leishman

Conniption Creek by Earl L. Carlson is good old-fashioned fun to read and enjoy. It is a wonderful example of satire, lampooning the righteous, indignant, and self-aggrandizing leaders of our community. Conniption Creek is facing a catastrophe, as flood waters threaten to sweep the very town itself into oblivion. Everyone has an opinion on what is about to happen, but the vast majority think that everyone and everything will be absolutely fine. Why? Well, the town’s holy woman, Saint Birdie Twine, has already assured them the town will be fine and that the floodwaters are receding. But are they? High above the town, the Native American Kayaya, leader of the indigenous Nimi’ipuu tribe, and the tribe’s young medicine woman Peo Peo watch the town slowly disappear under the water, firmly believing that the spirit of The Lake That No Longer Remembers Its Name will bring justice to the indigenous people and rid the valley of the white demons who have settled there.

Conniption Creek is a literary farce and satire at its best. Earl L. Carlson has made a literary career out of lampooning sacred cows, and this is not the first of his books I have read and chuckled endlessly over. What makes this story stand out is the depth of exceptional characters and their many foibles. The absurd and hilarious participants in this farcical tale are numerous, but a couple that stand out are the town’s mayor, Mitby Sather, and local holy man, Bishop Obediah Twine. I particularly loved Mayor Mitby Sather, who turned his less-than-stellar military career into a rising political career. Mitby seeks higher office, although he’s unsure just how high it should be, Governor, or perhaps President, but whatever, definitely higher than town mayor, that’s for sure. Bishop Obediah Twine has even higher aspirations than Sather. He wants to be Pope. One small problem, though, he isn’t actually a Catholic. He figures he'll just have to perform a miracle or two to really get God to sit up and take notice of him. These are just two of the absurd and hilarious characters that ultimately find themselves literally floating down the gurgler, as Conniption Creek conspires to sweep them all away and begin again. I loved this hilarious tale and highly recommend it.

Pikasho Deka

Conniption Creek by Earl L. Carlson follows the story of a small colony of settlers in the late nineteenth century. Kayayah, the leader of the Spirit Lake band of Nimi'ipuu, has learnt to accept living near the White settlers of Conniption City for the good of his people. When a devastating flood threatens to wash away the settlement, it brings havoc to the lives of the village's inhabitants. Onie Mattson is in jail, accused of rape by his wife at the insistence of Saint Birdie Twine, who has also assured people that the flood is a mere inconvenience. Molly Herkimer knows she is in danger, but still refuses to let go of her worldly possessions. Meanwhile, Onie is released from jail by Constable Hjalmer Kelliher. Bishop Obediah Twine is determined to rescue Molly.

Conniption Creek is an entertaining slice-of-life drama with a healthy dose of satire and comedy. The narrative almost felt like a Coen Brothers movie playing out with a large assortment of characters and dark humor sprinkled throughout the pages. Author Earl L. Carlson has crafted a deeply immersive setting, which makes the story all the more enjoyable. The characters are flawed people with their own quirks and unique personality traits. Although there are many featured characters, I found myself invested in every single one of their story arcs. Kayayah, Birdie, Onie, the mayor, and the rest will linger in your mind long after you've finished reading. The book is simply hilarious. If you enjoy well-written satirical dramas, I highly recommend it.