The Burning Gavel

Crime Mysteries by Norman Shabel

Fiction - Mystery - Legal
444 Pages
Reviewed on 03/02/2025
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Viga Boland for Readers' Favorite

Usually, a book described as a 444-page legal thriller is enough to send me searching the shelves for something else to read. Thankfully, a quick peruse of Norman Shabel’s bio made me pause. It’s impressive, and so is his novel, The Burning Gavel. I found myself so immersed in the plot line and the characters, that the pages just flew by and when I closed the novel, it was with a satisfied smile. What a great read The Burning Gavel turned out to be. The courtroom drama is centered on the case of a man, Tim Lowry, very badly burned in a deep steam pipe accident. His lawyer, Mel Levine, has a battle on his hands getting a just financial settlement from the four lawyers representing the companies being sued. Making matters worse, there is a biased judge who has it in for Levine and obstructs his every effort at a fair settlement, even going so far as jailing Levine overnight for contempt. Do Lowry and Levine have any hope of winning?

I became thoroughly involved in the courtroom dramatics, thanks to Norman Shabel’s excellent writing skills, but I most enjoyed what went on outside the courtroom: Mel Levine’s self-deprecating humor; his sexual/romantic escapades; his reminiscences of his family’s home life and his ongoing personal battle with his lawyering skills. In a lesser-skilled writer’s hands, such backstories seem intrusive; in Shabel’s hands, they embellish the story and bring the characters to life with their humanity. To describe The Burning Gavel as only a legal thriller is an injustice. Instead, it’s an often amusing and touching story about humanity at its worst and its best…and a must-read!

K.C. Finn

The Burning Gavel: Crime Mysteries by Norman Shabel pulls you into a legal thriller where one man’s fight for justice pits him against some seriously powerful enemies. Tim Lowry barely survives a chemical plant explosion, and now he’s determined to make those responsible pay. His only hope is Mel Levine, a sharp, street-smart lawyer who isn’t afraid to take on the big guys. But as Mel digs deeper, things get messy when witnesses start disappearing, secrets start piling up, and the danger gets very real. With time running out and the legal system stacked against them, Mel has to risk everything to uncover the truth before it’s too late.

Norman Shabel’s deep knowledge of the legal world makes this story feel real, and the tension never lets up. The courtroom scenes are gripping with sharp dialogue that conveys all the tension. However, the behind-the-scenes twists and high-stakes investigations kept me hooked as different plot elements bubbled under the surface until they suddenly hit me. Mel Levine is a great leading character—tough, smart, and willing to fight for what’s right, even when everything around them is stacked against success. The plot unfolds in a way that constantly raises the stakes, peeling back layers of corruption that feel all too believable and keeping a great pace with naturally delivered twists that don't feel gimmicky. Overall, The Burning Gavel is a thrilling read, perfect for anyone who loves legal dramas packed with suspense, moral dilemmas, and a fight for justice, and I definitely recommend it.

Anne-Marie Reynolds

The Burning Gavel is part of the Crime Mysteries series by Norman Shabel. Tim Lowry is back in the courtroom chasing justice after being left for dead following a chemical plant explosion. But the course of justice is never straightforward and Lowry is up against a biased judge, not to mention a corrupt defense team. His lawyer is Mel Levine, a man who fights for the truth at every turn and won’t take any nonsense. But this case proves to be his toughest yet, especially when he is thrown in jail. When a witness goes missing, it’s a race against time to find them but the lies and deceit are piling up. His personal demons are also haunting him, making things even more difficult for him, but will that just make him fight harder for the truth? This is his longest fight for survival yet, and he must win it, not just for Lowry but also for himself.

I’ve read many of the Crime Mysteries books by Norman Shabel, and The Burning Gavel is one of the best yet. A taut legal thriller, this is action all the way, a full-on rollercoaster ride that will leave you wanting more. It has a wonderful cast of characters, so many different people, yet each developed to the stage where you feel you know them personally. The twists and turns take you on a journey you’ll never forget, and the surprises and shocks just keep on coming – nothing less than I expect from these books – ensuring you won’t put this one down until you reach the last page. Norman Shabel writes compelling, exciting stories that draw you in and hold your attention all the way through, and if you love a good legal thriller, you’ll love this book.

Angelique Papayannopoulos

In The Burning Gavel, Norman Shabel spins a thrilling courtroom drama around the tenacious and strong-willed lawyer Mel Levin. He has taken on Tim Lowry's case, who remarkably survived a near-fatal workplace accident five years ago. After sustaining serious burns and enduring excruciating pain, Tim faces a daunting lawsuit against the chemical plant he had been working at when the explosion happened. Mel strives to achieve justice for his client while facing formidable odds, contending with the disappearance of a key witness, a biased judge, and corrupt lawyers who will defend their wealthy clients relentlessly. He even finds himself jailed for contempt of court. Will good win over evil, and will his unyielding pursuit of truth dismantle the web of lies, corruption, and deceit?

The Burning Gavel is a compelling legal thriller focusing on the lead character's confrontation with the system's ethics and morals. In a powerful and sinister plot, the story exposes a heartless betrayal in pursuing justice for an innocent man who lost everything he held dear. Through Norman Shabel's writing prowess and flashback narrative, Mel Levine's personality comes to life as the reader relates to his flaws and strengths, making him a likable and authentic character. Similarly, the antagonists slowly reveal their nefarious actions, building suspense and intrigue. Courtroom scene descriptions combine intricate plot structure with dramatic tension to engage the reader. The novel explores themes of trickery, honor, perseverance, and justice. The Burning Gavel is a nail-biting read that will appeal to readers who enjoy high-stakes courtroom dramas.

Manik Chaturmutha

Norman Shabel's The Burning Gavel is a crime mystery centered around the case of Tim Lowry, who was severely injured in an explosion at the Giant Chemical plant in Cobbstown, New Jersey. Five years later, Tim is back to seek justice, and he is not alone in his quest. Mel Levine, affectionately known as Melvin, is a tough, street-smart lawyer with a deep sense of justice, making him ideally suited for this case. He risks everything to discover the truth and soon finds himself entangled in a complex web of corruption, lies, and betrayal. This is the story of a man rediscovering himself while fighting for survival as danger escalates throughout the case. Justice must prevail, and Mel Levine is determined to see it through at any cost.

Norman Shabel's background as a trial lawyer enriches the narrative. He creates an actual courtroom experience for readers, avoiding fairytale embellishments. The characters are honest and humane and depict the reality of the world. The themes of justice and corruption are very much rooted in the plot, highlighting the often challenging battle for truth and justice. Sometimes, it even makes you question your whole life, which is a defining element of the narrative. The trial Shabel created is not just a trial in the courtroom but also life. Marina and Melvin's relationship and Melvin's backstory play an essential role in shaping his character as a lawyer. Melvin is flawed, which makes him unforgettable and relatable. Despite his imperfections, Melvin's dedication to seeking justice for Tim is commendable. While Melvin is the protagonist, the author ensures that other characters, such as Tim Lowry, are not overlooked. Tim's bravery and struggles are evident in Melvin's dialogues. Similarly, characters like Marina's father, Mordecai, and Melvin's friend, Max, have their influence on the plot. The story is an insightful introduction to the realities of the legal system. While the plot is about getting justice for Tim, it is also about Melvin's emotional journey to find that lost spark of what being a lawyer means to him. Overall, The Burning Gavel is more than just a tale of justice; it is filled with meaningful life lessons and captures the essence of friendship, love, and honor. It is a compelling page-turner.