Surviving Southwood Avenue

A Story of Family Secrets and Resilience

Fiction - Drama
276 Pages
Reviewed on 10/24/2024
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Review Exchange Program, which is open to all authors and is completely free. Simply put, you agree to provide an honest review an author's book in exchange for the author doing the same for you. What sites your reviews are posted on (B&N, Amazon, etc.) and whether you send digital (eBook, PDF, Word, etc.) or hard copies of your books to each other for review is up to you. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email, and be sure to describe your book or include a link to your Readers' Favorite review page or Amazon page.

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Book Donation Program, which was created to help nonprofit and charitable organizations (schools, libraries, convalescent homes, soldier donation programs, etc.) by providing them with free books and to help authors garner more exposure for their work. This author is willing to donate free copies of their book in exchange for reviews (if circumstances allow) and the knowledge that their book is being read and enjoyed. To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email. Be sure to tell the author who you are, what organization you are with, how many books you need, how they will be used, and the number of reviews, if any, you would be able to provide.

Author Biography

Melissa (McEndree) Simonye is a wife, mother, small business owner, and retired elementary school teacher of twenty-five years. She explored her love for writing in high school by expressing herself through poetry. She grew up in Ohio and graduated from college with a master’s degree in education. As an educator, her passion was inspiring her students to love reading by exposing them to authentic literature that spoke to her students’ individuality. Reading about courageous people also fascinated Melissa, especially strong women who made a mark in history. Melissa has lived in Colorado since 2003. She now works with her husband running their small business. Whenever she can escape her busy life, she exercises, travels, reads books, and writes at her kitchen table, surrounded by her two cats and two dogs. This is Melissa’s first novel, inspired by her extraordinary grandmother’s life experiences.
For more information, visit www.melissasimonye.com.

    Book Review

Reviewed by P. Rosenthal for Readers' Favorite

Surviving Southwood Avenue is a fictional biography that starts in 1920s Ohio. Clara is an “independent, fierce, quick-witted” and beautiful woman. Even though she is obsessed with her first love, Richard, Clara ends up marrying Frank. Their seemingly stable life is disrupted when Clara rekindles her relationship with Richard, ultimately choosing to run away with him. Her family is left shattered. Unaware of the dark secrets it holds, Frank moves Charles, Eleanor, Bob, and Stella to a boarding house. The children decide to remain silent, fearing both the abusive matron's retributions and not wanting to upset their father further. This poignant story, based on author Melissa Simonye's grandmother Stella's life, delves into a family's heartbreak and eventual triumphs.

"…if you only focus on the ‘whys’ in life, then you will never understand the ‘why nots’ in life.” The vivid descriptions create a mental movie of one family’s life during the 1920s and 1930s. Prepare for a raw emotional experience. Surviving Southwood Avenue stuns the senses with its pure honesty. The story's intimacy amplifies themes of love, betrayal, weakness, and survival. The believable dialogue enriches the reality of each character’s experience and allows the reader to become invested in their welfare. Stella, the star protagonist, is an extraordinary spirit and a model of self-worth. Set time aside. This is a fast-paced, can’t-put-it-down book. Melissa Simonye’s labor of love is a fantastic tribute to her grandmother, Stella. Fans of memoirs, historical fiction, and drama will not want to miss Surviving Southwood Avenue.

Ankita Shukla

When adults fail to nurture the ones they should protect, kids create their own rulebook for survival. Melissa Simonye describes the possible long-term impact of this failure in Surviving Southwood Avenue: A Story of Family Secrets and Resilience. When his wife, Cara, runs away with her past lover, Frank must choose between losing his four kids to social services or finding a solution that will allow him to earn a living and take care of his kids without raising any alarm. Since he does not wish to lose his kids, he chooses the second option - he places his kids in a boarding house. Little does he know that this house will introduce his young children to extreme horrors capable of breaking their spirits from the inside out. Stella, his four-year-old daughter, becomes the main target of deplorable acts of physical and mental assaults that nobody, let alone a child, should ever go through.

Inspired by the true events, Surviving Southwood Avenue counsels parents and caretakers to pay attention to the unsaid words of their children and notice their sudden changes in behavior. Melissa Simonye is a non-judgmental narrator. She explores the characters with an open mind. In Stella's voice, the narration provides a view into the innocent world of a child -- this adds another level to understanding the unbelievable impact of such atrocities on a child's mind and heart. As a reader, I could not help but wish justice would prevail; this desire and the well-written plot forced me to keep flipping the pages until the very end. Although Stella's story is quite dark and gut-wrenching, it is also a testament to the strength and perseverance of human character. Surviving Southwood Avenue by Melissa Simonye urges society to do better for those who can't protect themselves. At the same time, she inspires the survivors to rewrite their story.

Lucinda E Clarke

When Stella’s mother ran away when she was only four years old, her father moved into a boarding house with his four children. Working two jobs, Frank left Charles, Eleanor, Bob, and little Stella in the care of Margaret Spangler, an unbalanced and mentally ill woman. During the five years they lived there, most especially after Frank moved out, their situation became even worse. They were beaten, half-starved, mentally abused, and worse, from the age of six, Stella was molested by Albert, their landlady’s teenage son. Surviving Southwood Avenue by Melissa Simonye, Stella’s granddaughter, was written from discussions with Stella and the notes her daughter transcribed before Stella died at the age of ninety-eight. A story of survival, a woman who came to terms with each horror that she encountered, and led a successful and happy life.

Surviving Southwood Avenue by Melissa Simonye is an amazing book about a time when young children did not have modern attitudes toward adults. While they were severely abused, they kept their secrets, telling no one how cruelly they were treated. This partly fictional memoir is beautifully written as the characters leap off the page, especially Stella, and we share every hardship she suffers. While this is a harrowing read, it reminds or informs us of a time when children were seen and not heard and also how a young child believes how helpless they are. It also shows the strength of the human spirit. While both Margaret Spangler, who ran the Southwood Avenue guest house, and Stella’s mother Clara were both mentally ill, there was never any mention of them getting help. It's ironic that had social services rescued the children, they may well have been happier in stable homes. I also wondered about their father Frank, who appeared to have little insight into the conditions his children were suffering. Today we live in a much kinder world and this book is a lesson that reminds us of it. Inspirational.

Ronél Steyn

Melissa Simonye pays homage to her family in the historical fiction novel, Surviving Southwood Avenue. Stella was born the youngest of four children in April 1916. Her mother suddenly leaves her father and siblings the day after Stella’s fourth birthday. Soon after, they all move into the boarding house on Southwood Avenue because her father is unable to keep the house they once lived in. What follows is an account of the conditions the siblings endured while under the care of Mrs. Spangler and her son, Albert. It is a story of hope and survival and one family’s ability to grow when the world around them tries to break them down.

Author Melissa Simonye shares the heartfelt tale of her grandmother in this riveting true story based in Columbus, Ohio. Written in the first-person narrative from the perspective of Stella, we share in her struggles to survive a life that no child should endure. Characters are relatable and written with an abundance of personality. The author pulls on the heartstrings of every reader and keeps them glued from start to finish. Emphasis is placed on bravery and the courage shown by the characters. I loved looking at the book cover and finally understanding the significance behind it. Even with the subtle instances of torture and abuse, I would gladly recommend Surviving Southwood Avenue to young adult readers as well. This is a story of hope and love in the face of cruelty and how one person can truly become the matriarch of a family and inspire the world.

Frank Mutuma

In Surviving Southwood Avenue by Melissa Simonye, Clara was abused by her father while growing up. He was a heavy drinker, and after some time her mother decided to leave. Clara was meant to go to her sister, but she did not want to. Luckily, her boyfriend, Richard, talks to his parents, and they accept Clara moving in with them. After Clara breaks up with Richard, she meets Frank, and they get married. Frank is hard-working and ensures his family is provided for. Things are well until Richard returns. Clara runs off with her old boyfriend, which results in a lot of suffering for Frank and the kids. Frank is forced to sell their home and move to a boarding house. The boarding house is challenging for the kids, especially Stella, who is the youngest. How will things turn out for their family?

I loved the fact that Surviving Southwood Avenue by Melissa Simonye was inspired by real events. It takes one on a roller-coaster of emotions as one sees the consequences of broken families, especially on children. This thought-provoking work also got me thinking about mental health issues and the importance of guardians listening to their children and also looking at other subtle signs of unhappiness and distress. Melissa ensured all the events were captured vividly, which made one invested in the storyline. The characters were well-developed, and the steady narration also added to the overall beauty of this amazing work. This was a great read, and I look forward to more by this wonderful author.